Outside Eats
Menu
Delete Account
This will permanently delete your account and all saved restaurants. This cannot be undone.
Cancel
← Back to Restaurant Guide

Cookiez by Sara

Dessert$

A Foster City cookie shop baking small batch gourmet cookies daily, with Heirloom coffee, matcha, Mitchell’s ice cream, milkshakes, and a hot cookie bowl, plus pink box gifts and shipping nationwide.


Cookiez by Sara at 969A Edgewater Boulevard in Foster City is a cookie shop built around what its founder Sara calls two key ingredients: quality and care. Cookies are baked fresh in Foster City in small batches, and the menu ranges from a classic chocolate chip to creative flavors like S’mores, Cookiez ‘N Cream, and a TCHO 66% dark chocolate sea salt cookie. Premium flavors add a dollar per cookie.

The signature is the pink box. Customers can build a box of 4, 6, or 12 cookies, mixing favorites or doubling up on the ones they love, or choose a curated bestseller box for gifting. Orders can be picked up in Foster City, delivered locally, or shipped nationwide. For larger orders, the shop does corporate and event catering, with cookies that can be customized with a company logo or event design, and gluten friendly cookies are available by preorder.

The shop is also a dessert stop. Coffee and espresso come from Heirloom Coffee Roasters, with drinks like the Spanish Latte, Cookie Butter Latte, and Strawberry Matcha. The dessert menu has Mitchell’s Ice Cream scooped in the shop, creamy milkshakes, affogato, and a Hot Cookie Bowl. Birthday parties run about 90 minutes with hosted sundae making, cookies, and drinks, and the team handles setup and cleanup. A loyalty program is available through the Cookiez by Sara app.

Diner Notes

0 comments
No comments yet. Be the first.
Like the guide? Buy us a coffee. We're a small Peninsula team. Tips keep every restaurant, video and Passport free. Support Outside Eats